Last night I was sitting down on the toilet and when I glanced down, the insides of my thighs were a pale blue. Naturally I spent a few minutes wondering what the hell I'd been doing recently, and then realized that it was the same pale blue as my jeans. Holy shit, my jeans were turning my skin blue. I rubbed at them a little and
nothing changed. It's like my skin has been dyed, or something. I look like my inner thighs are in early frostbite stages or something.
The whole point of that was that I'm in this heavy stage of procrastination right now. I've got a big speech tomorrow? I haven't written my note cards out, I haven't practiced, and I'm still not even technically done with my outline. I haven't put any of my bibliography in there, and I don't know if I even have a qualified bibliography. It's sort of fucked up, but I've reached this state of academic non-caring that scares me a little. I'm in college, and I love learning, but I just don't care about any of it. This is a dangerous thought process to have, all things considered, since Hope pays for a lot of my tuition and losing it means that I'm probably not going to keep going here.
I think this speech class has created in me this monster that cares about the class, but not about the speeches. I think they're far too heavily structured, I think they have juxtaposed expectations (I have to be short, concise, and scholarly while also being conversational? Really.) and I think far too much emphasis is put on the neatness of it all. I feel like the truly amazing speeches aren't ones that were grafted into perfection, but the ones that came from a place of deep meaning.
I also keep picking these topics that sound awesome at the time but end up being horrible. Right now I'm explaining why homeschooling isn't a good idea, but basically every source I can find states that homeschooling is good for various reasons, ignoring everything that I've personally seen happen. Look, I know that in certain situations, homeschooling might be the best thing that happens to a kid, but most of the time, there are too many factors working against them. I know four different individuals who have been homeschooled, and nothing good happened to them. My sister, who became isolated and dependent on me for social interaction; Ashley, who was left at home alone with too much free time and who was allowed to do the work if she felt like it; Megan, who's homeschooling has led her to extreme social needs and basically turned her into a slut; and Jamie, who's homeschooling has made her into her mother's puppet to do with what she wants, and who keeps getting caught doing bad things in the houses she babysits in. Maybe homeschooling is okay for their education, at least in Megan and Jamie's case, but the social issues they're going to have are far worse than anything education can count for. Jamie will become a unhealthily dependent young woman, and Megan is already someone who will do anything for attention, even sexual acts. She's younger than my sixteen year old sister. My sister herself was forced into a curriculum that held little interest for her, being religious based, and while she may have improved her behavior from her public middle school state, she became withdrawn and restless. My father was forced to basically put his work on hold to school her, and my grandmother would travel from her home two hours away to help out; several times I was come to for help because they couldn't understand the curriculum, which has vastly changed since they were schooled. There are so many things that can go wrong with homeschooling unless strict, personal attention is paid, and that just hasn't happened in all of the instances I've encountered. So why are there no professional articles explaining that? Why is it that all of the hyper-religious, controlling bullshit gets all of the attention?
Children need to be controlled and guided in order to attain moral standards, yes, but I heavily believe that a social group needs to be a deciding factor in those moral standards. If I had simply been homeschooled and taught everything about society by my parents, I would believe that homosexuality was wrong; I would believe that black people were causing huge issues that aren't necessarily their faults; I would struggle with my own sense of freedoms and personal desires. My parents aren't bad people -- they're the most amazing people I know, but I don't think that their standards should apply to me. I think that I should be allowed to make my own decisions based on what the world has to offer, and that means being exposed to it as a child and bearing witness to the indecencies and wrongs out there. Yes, this might mean that I have to see things children shouldn't, but it also means that I recognize it as a bad thing, rather than a foreign thing. I have never, in my nineteen years of life, been exposed to drugs; none of my friends, even the ones that do drugs, have tried to make me do it. I have never smoked, I have never drunk alcohol, and I have never had sex. I have friends that smoke, I have friends that drink copiously, and I have friends that have sex. I recognize that it's their choice to do what they want to with themselves, and my own moral codes mean that those things aren't what I want to do with myself.
I also think that a huge part of schooling needs to be competition; and not just competition, but competition with peers. Maybe a homeschooler looks at tests and says, I need to do better than public school students or private school students, but I can look at a test and say, I'm gonna do better than Kevin on this, because English is my goddamn subject. I had faces to look at, and I had goals that I wanted to meet based on them. My teachers weren't my mom or dad, who I would rather die than disappoint, even with something as basic as a test score. There were lines between my education and my home life. I think that homeschooling puts a heavy weight on students; there's no separation between what your parents expect from you and what your teachers expect from you. There's no one that can really help you in the place of the other.
Again, I do recognize that sometimes, homeschooling is what's best. Homeschooling can work. It's possible, and you can give your kid all the extracurriculars, you can give them other social circles. But it takes a lot of work, and it takes a lot of time, and it takes a lot of tears. It takes a parent quitting their job and simultaneously spending more money, it takes effort to learn ahead of your child so that you can adequately explain what they're learning. Most parents are not teachers; they don't know how to teach, unlike people who go to school to specifically learn it, and even those people have specific areas of expertise.
Basically, tl;dr, this speech is seriously hard to write, despite all of the things in that huge section up there, because no one else can write this without looking incredibly prejudiced. It's impossible to write against homeschooling because homeschooling caters perfectly to the people who are looking at it; it means controlling your kids, it means having a hand in their education, it looks like it costs less in the long run (I can't find numbers that agree, and none from scholarly sources) and it's easy enough to stick them in ballet or something and hope that they make friends. And if you say anything against homeschooling, they'll go after you; I've read enough articles to know that they're fiercely protective of their schooling style, which is fine, but I also feel like they're only showing the good in their system. Everyone knows the faults of public schooling, but homeschooling only has good media coverage because most of the time, no one cares about the details I've listed. Megan's just one more slut in the world, and who's to say that homeschooling even caused that? Ashley's just one more student who didn't go to college, and public schools are full of those. Jamie's just one more kid with messed up parents, and that's not homeschooling's fault. Maybe those things are true, but I think that homeschooling definitely did have an influence on them, and I think that homeschooling should at least acknowledge that it is not a perfect way of teaching children.
Hmmm. I wish I could just print that out and read it. Damn structures.